Skip to content

Town Meeting takeaways: Winchester weighed the cost of acting — and waiting

Members vote 36-122 against using eminent domain on wooded parcel, back $400,000 for special education

Conservation Commission Chair Tracy Olson presents Article 26, the proposed eminent domain taking of about 13.4 acres at Forest Ridge, to Town Meeting at Winchester High School Nov. 9. Olson called a taking “the only available path to retain this land for the public good” and cited a June appraisal of $2.85 million. Members rejected the taking 36-122. WINCHESTER NEWS STAFF PHOTO / WILL DOWD

Table of Contents

Twice on Nov. 9, Winchester Town Meeting members were warned that holding back would cost the town. They acted on one warning and set the other aside.

Supporters of an eminent domain taking at Forest Ridge said delay could mean losing 13.4 wooded acres off Forest Circle to development. Members voted 36-122, with one abstention, against the taking, which needed a two-thirds majority. Later that night, they put $400,000 into a special education reserve that was down to $3,780.55.

The two votes showed the calculation members carried through all three sessions of the fall meeting, held Nov. 5, 9 and 12 at Winchester High School: what the town could afford to commit before next year’s budget takes shape, and what it could not.

Across 45 articles, they approved a roughly $4.8 million capital plan; halved a payment toward retiree health care and a study of the Sanborn Carriage House; rejected a $50,000 master plan for Nutile Field; and cleared the way for a new house at the Ledges.

Forest Ridge falls short

The vote leaves the Select Board without authority to take the land. A Nov. 3 memo from Town Counsel Karis North said a taking requires both a two-thirds Town Meeting vote and a Select Board majority. It warned that the town’s offer to an owner “is the floor, not the ceiling.”

Conservation Commission Chair Tracy Olson told members a June appraisal valued the parcel at $2.85 million. Because a developer has the land under agreement, she said, a taking was “the only available path to retain this land for the public good.”

Brian Vernaglia, of Precinct 4, a Planning Board member, questions the proposed Forest Ridge taking from the balcony of the Winchester High School auditorium Nov. 9. Citing the town’s earlier eminent domain taking of the Washington and Swanton streets parcel, he urged the Select Board to negotiate a price instead of asking Town Meeting for “a blank check.” Members rejected the taking 36-122. WINCHESTER NEWS STAFF PHOTO / WILL DOWD

Olson cited a $250,000 state earmark, a $425,000 state grant and a federal grant of up to $1 million that can be used only with the landowner’s agreement.

Opponents focused on what a jury might award. The town assessor told members the parcels are assessed at about $4.9 million.

Select Board member Bill McGonigle said Bell Point, the buyer under agreement, had told the board it would challenge any taking and could present a valuation close to $5 million.

“Once we take it, we can’t go back, and that’s just not a risk that I’m willing to take,” McGonigle said.

The Select Board split 2-2 on a recommendation, with Michael Bettencourt and Michelle Prior in favor and McGonigle and Chair Anthea Brady opposed. The Finance Committee recommended against the taking with one dissent, and the Housing Partnership Board voted 7-3 to urge a delay.

Diab Jerius, of Precinct 8, said he has watched green space turn into houses since moving to town in about 1996.

“I cannot go around my neighborhood and remove the houses and put back the woods that used to be there,” Jerius said.

In May, Town Meeting rejected a voluntary $3 million purchase of the land, 105-59.

School reserve restored in full

The $400,000 transfer from free cash passed on a voice vote after members rejected an amendment by Megan Blackwell, of Precinct 7, to cut it to $200,000.

School Committee Chair Timothy Matthews said the reserve, drawn down twice to help balance school budgets, held that amount as of Sept. 30.

“That isn’t prudence, friends. That’s austerity by habit,” Matthews said of leaving the reserve empty while the town holds historically high reserves.

Finance Committee Chair Kathryn Hughes said the committee recommended against the transfer and that its own reserve fund is available for emergencies. The Select Board backed the full amount 3-1, with Prior favoring $200,000.

Select Board member Michelle Prior speaks from the upper level of the Winchester High School auditorium Nov. 9 before moving to cut a transfer to the town’s retiree health care trust from $350,000 to $175,000. Members adopted the cut 98-46, then approved the smaller amount unanimously. WINCHESTER NEWS STAFF PHOTO / WILL DOWD

Retiree health payment halved

Earlier Nov. 9, members cut a transfer from free cash to the town’s retiree health care trust from $350,000 to $175,000 on a 98-46 clicker vote, then approved it unanimously.

Brady said the trust holds about $9.8 million against a liability of about $119.7 million.

Prior, who moved the cut, said Town Meeting could spend $1.3 million in free cash before spring, before the town knows what next year’s budget looks like.

“We are reducing the flexibility to fund next year’s budget by taking out free cash in this and other articles,” Prior said.

Carriage House, Ledges and capital spending

On Nov. 12, members voted 85-68 for a $25,000 study of refurbishing the Sanborn Carriage House at 15 High St., which has sat unused since the 1990s beside Ambrose School. They first adopted an amendment by Maura Sullivan of Precinct 1, 99-54, which halved the School Committee’s $50,000 request, drew most of the money from leftover consulting funds and dropped demolition from the study.

The Select Board and the Finance Committee had opposed the original request over its use of free cash.

Members then voted 97-31 to release about 20,000 square feet at 7 Wainwright Road from open space set aside under the Ledges condominiums’ 1985 special permit. They voted 97-32, with two abstentions, to rezone the lot for one single-family home.

The Planning Board opposed both 3-2, and North said the condominium board’s offer of up to $100,000 from the sale for affordable housing is not legally binding.

School Committee member John Bellaire of Precinct 2 presents Article 30, a study of the Sanborn Carriage House at 15 High St., to Town Meeting Nov. 12. Members cut the School Committee’s $50,000 request to $25,000, 99-54, then approved the study 85-68. WINCHESTER NEWS STAFF PHOTO / WILL DOWD

“We owe it to the town boards and residents who negotiated that agreement 40 years ago to keep the promise that we made to Winchester,” said Planning Board member Brian Vernaglia, who opposed the change.

The Capital Planning Committee’s package, approved the first night mostly without dissent, includes a $1.1 million fire engine not expected until 2028; $900,000 for walkways and stairs at Lincoln School; $720,000 for streets, sidewalks and traffic calming; and $410,000 for heating, cooling and building-control design work in the schools.

Other actions

Members approved $870,500 of $920,500 in community preservation projects, including $400,000 to ready the Packer-Ellis clay tennis courts for bidding and $300,000 for a Leonard Field pavilion. A $50,000 master plan for Nutile Field failed 65-93, with two abstentions.

They unanimously approved $173,724 for permitting software after Town Manager Christopher Senior withdrew a request for budget software.

A revised sidewalk snow bylaw requires at least 36 inches of cleared path and raises fines from at most $10 to $25, $50 and $75.

Members made the Committee on Names a standing committee, rejecting 62-75 an amendment by Heather von Mering, of Precinct 8, to remove the moderator’s seat. They accepted about 16 acres of conservation land, 98-46, barely clearing two-thirds, and unanimously rezoned the Christopher Columbus Society’s property at 18 Raymond Place for a home.

Article 39, a petition to rezone 114 Church St., never reached a vote. Moderator Philip Frattaroli said the proponents asked the Planning Board not to make the recommendation state zoning law requires, so the article was not properly before the meeting and can return without a two-year wait.

Frattaroli ruled that Article 43, a petition seeking separate ballot votes for unrelated parts of future tax overrides, was not properly before the meeting. Articles 44 and 45 were indefinitely postponed, as was Article 3 on the consent agenda.

Town Meeting members stand to applaud Allan Rogers and John Suhrbier, who are retiring from the Housing Partnership Board, at the start of the Nov. 9 session at Winchester High School. Moderator Philip Frattaroli said the two have served 70 years between them. WINCHESTER NEWS STAFF PHOTO / WILL DOWD

What comes next

Town Meeting adjourned at about 10:56 p.m. Nov. 12, leaving the Nov. 16 reserve date unused.

Hughes said Senior plans to deliver a revenue estimate in December to guide next year’s budget. McGonigle said the Waterfield project could close in December or January, and the Capital Planning Committee expects to return next spring with a scope and funding options for Town Hall.

Olson warned before the vote that delay could cost up to $1.7 million in grants and earmarks for Forest Ridge. Bell Point has not said what it plans next for the land.

Will Dowd is a Massachusetts journalist who covers municipal government and community life for Winchester News. He is also the founder and editor of The Marblehead Independent, a reader-funded digital newsroom.

Winchester News is a non-profit organization supported by our community. If you appreciate having local Winchester news, please donate to support our work, and subscribe to our free weekly newsletter. Copyright 2026 Winchester News Group, Inc. Copying and sharing with written permission only.

Latest

Local News Day to be held at Winchester Public Library on Nov. 21

Local News Day to be held at Winchester Public Library on Nov. 21

The following was submitted by Grace Siciliano: On Saturday, Nov. 21, come to the Winchester Public Library, 80 Washington St., for Local News Day, from 12-1:30 p.m. Local News Day will be an opportunity to learn about some organizations in town which provide reliable information about local

  Subscribe