Skip to content

Winchester volleyball falls to Brookline in state semifinal

Loss was two points in decisive fifth set

Winchester High freshman volleyball player Maggie Angevine (12) blocks an attempted shot by a Bishop Feehan player during a Division 1 Elite 8 home matchup on Nov. 13. Senior Viviana Cella (7) is alongside for support. The Red & Black went on to win the match, 3-1 to advance to a state semifinal encounter against Brookline at Arlington, where they lost a 3-2 heartbreaker to the Warriors five days later. WINCHESTER NEWS PHOTO / RICK NAPLES

Table of Contents

The words “heartbreaker” and “bitter” are often overused words to describe tough losses. But even those words cannot accurately depict what took place at Arlington High School on Wednesday night (Nov. 18), when the Winchester High volleyball team (20-4), the third seed, faced off against Brookline (21-1), the second seed, in a Division 1 state semifinal matchup.

The Red & Black couldn’t get any closer to victory, while taking the Warriors to the max, only to come up short, 3-2. Brookline will now take on Central Catholic (23-1), the top seed, on Saturday night (Nov. 21) at Newton South High School, starting at 7:30 p.m.

The Raiders defeated Franklin (21-3), the fifth seed, in the other competitive state semifinal encounter, 3-2. A total of 35 teams made the postseason in Division 1, and as fate would have it the power rankings were accurate, with four of the top five seeds ending up among the Final Four.

But that’s small consolation for Coach John Fleming and his players.

“It was a brutal ending to an amazing season,” Fleming said. “It was an unbelievable match that went back and forth. I thought we played the first set well enough to win, but unfortunately too many missed serves along the way (allowed) Brookline to hang around.”

The Red & Black had multiple set points, but just couldn't finish them off. The second set, in particular, they battled back to a 17-17 tie, before Brookline went on a run to win it.

Trailing 2-0 at any point in a season is not a recipe for success, but in the playoffs, it’s even more difficult with everything on the line. But good teams like Winchester still know how to comeback.

“I think the next two sets really defined the character of this team,” said Fleming. “Their will to win is how this team will be remembered.”

At that point, the Winchester girls went all-out, fighting hard for every point.

“Winning that third set gave us lots of confidence. We then rode that momentum into the fourth set, where we jumped out to a huge lead, and as a result were able to control the full (fourth) set,” said Fleming.

It was onto the fifth set, which is such a “tricky thing” since it only goes to 15, according to Fleming. The coach then added, “we got down, but tied it up, before switching sides when Brookline got that eighth point to take the lead, 8-7.”

The Warriors extended the lead to 11-8, but once again Winchester fought back, only to trail again by three, 14-11.

But they weren’t giving up after securing the next two points. Unfortunately, Brookline turned in a “great play” to secure the win, said Fleming, who went on to say, “give Brookline all the credit in the world. They played great, and are well-coached. In the end, however, they were two points better than us in the final set. It’s heartbreaking to be that close to the state finals, (and lose). The girls worked so hard to get there, and I feel bad that we couldn't find a way to win this match.”

But one match doesn’t diminish so many successes that they have had the last two months.

“We had a remarkable season going undefeated in the Middlesex League without losing a single set,” said Fleming. “We played statistically the toughest schedule in the entire state. We did beat Brookline earlier in the year, while also beating Oliver Ames. It was their only loss in two years. We also won three home playoff matches to win our first title since 2019. It was the sectional championship back then, while the trophy now signifies teams that have reached the Final Four. We have so much to be proud of, and as a team have represented the town, program and our families very well.”

Stars shine through a memorable season

With 20 wins, it goes without saying that Winchester had its share of Middlesex League all-stars, and All-League players. Hazel Lovins, Maddie Crooks, Defne Mergen and Kaiyal Kumaran made the all-star team for the second year in a row.

The All-League selections were Lovins, Crooks and Mergen. They were among the Top 6 players in a 12-team league. Lovins also took home league MVP honors for the second straight year, while also making the Division 1 All-State team, along with Crooks. It’s the second time in as many years that Lovins made this elite statewide squad.

Joe McConnell is a longtime, award-winning sports editor for numerous North Shore publications. He has been covering Winchester sports for the News since November 2024 and is currently its Sports Editor. He can be reached at editor@winchesternews.org.

Winchester News is a non-profit organization supported by our community. If you appreciate having local Winchester news, please donate to support our work, and subscribe to our free weekly newsletter. Copyright 2026 Winchester News Group, Inc. Copying and sharing with written permission only.

Latest

Winchester Girl Scout Maya Papenhousen earns Gold Award

Winchester Girl Scout Maya Papenhousen earns Gold Award

This past summer, Maya Papenhausen, a recent Winchester High School Class of 2026 graduate and member of Girl Scout Troop 77026, completed her Take Action project and earned her Girl Scout Gold Award, presented by the Girl Scouts of Eastern Massachusetts. Papenhausen is the 40th Winchester resident to earn the

Town of Winchester highlights improvements to Sandy’s Island at Mill Pond

Town of Winchester highlights improvements to Sandy’s Island at Mill Pond

The following was submitted by the Winchester Town Clerk’s Office: The Town of Winchester is pleased to highlight recent landscape improvements and ongoing preservation efforts at Sandra S. Rodgers Island Trust, a scenic feature of Mill Pond in the heart of Winchester’s downtown. The improvements are part of

Winchester High School hosts Fall College Signing Day

Winchester High School hosts Fall College Signing Day

On Monday, Nov. 16, the Winchester High School Athletic Department hosted a Fall College Signing Day. The event honored four student-athletes: Stella DeChristoforo (Assumption University, field hockey), Carys Gugliotta (Saint Anselm, softball), Sophie Shapiro (Lehigh University, soccer) and Raffi Parseghian (College of the Holy Cross, rowing). A bigger production

  Subscribe